St Mirren boss McLeish challenges governance behind Scottish youth reforms
St Mirren manager Craig McLeish has criticised Scottish football's governance as the Scottish FA seeks support for measures to give younger players more first-team opportunities. According to BBC Sport, McLeish questioned whether clubs should wield such influence over changes affecting player development and the future of Scotland's national team.
Watch the highlights:
SFA chief football officer Craig Mulholland and the governing body have been discussing the proposals with Scottish Professional Football League clubs. The plans included starting two under-21 players in cup competitions and requiring that age group to account for at least 6% of available league minutes over a season. BBC Sport described suggestions that the proposals had been watered down as media speculation, rather than a confirmed decision.
McLeish argued that club interests could obstruct reforms intended to benefit the national side. He acknowledged that owners and managers were focused on their own teams, but questioned why those priorities should determine Scotland's broader development strategy. He said meaningful progress would be difficult without changes to governance, while expressing doubt that such changes would happen.
The 36-year-old, who worked in St Mirren's academy before becoming manager earlier this year, also said the debate needed to extend beyond quotas, league structure and a national training base. In his view, shortcomings begin with how children are taught at the earliest stages of playing football. He called attention to coaching methods, playing formats and the level of expertise available to young players.
McLeish stressed the importance of volunteers to grassroots football but argued that their contribution needed to be accompanied by better education and coaching standards. He compared the experience with swimming and gymnastics, where he said children receive instruction from qualified teachers or coaches. His remarks placed early learning alongside first-team opportunities as an issue for the development pathway.
The Press Association, whose reporting of McLeish's comments was cited by the BBC, said it had approached the SFA for a response. The remarks followed comments on Thursday from Dundee head coach Steven Pressley, who supported creating a national football centre and also criticised the existing structure.
Comments
0No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!