Rugby concussion claims await ruling after disclosure deadline dispute
Hundreds of former rugby players are awaiting a decision on whether their neurological injury claims can proceed after a two-day hearing became dominated by missed disclosure deadlines. The Guardian reported that Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter had finished hearing arguments at the Royal Courts of Justice and were considering the future of the litigation.
Watch the highlights:
The players allege that professional negligence by rugby's governing bodies caused neurological damage. The defendants are World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union, the Welsh Rugby Union and the Rugby Football League. The hearing concerned whether the cases could continue towards trial, rather than a determination of whether those allegations were established. A decision is expected in the coming days, according to the report.
The court had been due to consider which claims should become test cases for the wider group. Instead, lawyers argued over relief from sanctions following a failure to complete disclosure of documents connected with the testing players underwent when joining the action. KP Law, which took over the case in July, had been given until 30 October to remedy problems with that disclosure process.
According to The Guardian, all 378 rugby union claimants and most of the 173 rugby league claimants had previously had their cases struck out because the former legal firm, Rylands Garth, had failed to disclose relevant documents. Senior Master Cook granted relief conditional on KP Law correcting the position by the deadline. The firm says it has supplied another 2,000 documents and is seeking until January to provide the rest.
Lawyers for World Rugby, the RFU and the WRU argued that the cases should remain struck out. World Rugby's Nina Goolamali KC and the RFU's Neil Block KC challenged the feasibility of the proposed October 2028 trial given the disclosure delays. The WRU's Michael Kent KC also criticised the continuing dispute over documents.
For the players, Paul Downes KC identified 39 claimants, comprising 22 from rugby union and 17 from rugby league, whom he said were substantially compliant with court orders. He acknowledged that the defence could contest that assessment. Downes also warned that leaving the remaining cases struck out would lead to further litigation over which claimants were in breach at the October deadline.
Comments
0No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!