Rugby brain injury cases face fresh uncertainty over missing medical records
Two lawsuits involving hundreds of rugby players with brain injuries face renewed uncertainty after another missed deadline for medical documents, The Guardian reported on November 18. Lawyers representing the players are seeking an extension until January to complete disclosure, with the future of the proceedings now dependent on decisions by Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter.
Watch the highlights:
The latest hearings had been intended to advance preparations for a trial beginning next October, according to the report. Both sides were expected to submit shortlists of possible test cases. Instead, attention has shifted to whether breaches of earlier court orders mean the cases stand struck out. The claimants have previously been granted relief from that sanction and are seeking more time to comply.
Lawyers for World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and the Welsh Rugby Union argue that outstanding medical records prevent them from completing the test-case selection process. The Guardian reported that disclosure deadlines had repeatedly been missed, including another in October. Paul Downes KC, the players' lead counsel, had already acknowledged the precarious position of the claims during proceedings in June.
KP Law took over representation of the players in June from Rylands Garth, which is no longer involved. According to The Guardian, KP Law has since supplied another 2,000 documents concerning medical testing. The firm argues that its recent work represents substantial progress, while Downes has criticised the condition of the case when the new legal team inherited it.
Significant gaps nevertheless remain. The court heard that only 36 of the 385 players in the rugby union case had letters of diagnosis, prompting concern from Mr Justice Cotter. Downes also said Rylands Garth lacked a single comprehensive database tracking which records had been supplied. He alleged that access to its files had been withheld pending an exit agreement with KP Law.
Downes maintains that the litigation can still be put back on course and has urged that it be preserved if possible. The report did not establish that the requested extension had been granted or that the lawsuits had definitively ended. For now, the unresolved disclosure dispute leaves the planned selection of test cases dependent on the judges' response.
Comments
0No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!