Joe Cordina assault trial hears competing accounts of petrol station fight

Former boxing world champion Joe Cordina's assault trial has heard competing accounts of a confrontation at a Cardiff petrol station, with prosecutors alleging he retaliated rather than acted to protect himself. According to BBC reporting from Cardiff Magistrates' Court, a second charge of assault by beating was dropped on Tuesday, leaving one charge concerning the incident on 27 February.

Watch the highlights:

The case concerns an altercation involving Jamie O'Brien, who had previously admitted assault by beating. The court heard that the incident at a Texaco garage in Pentwyn became public days later when Wales Online published footage recorded by a witness. CCTV showing events unfolding over several minutes was also played during the hearing.

Prosecutor Alex Orndal said the footage showed Cordina leaving his car while refuelling and approaching O'Brien on the nearby pavement. He alleged that, after O'Brien pushed Cordina with his shoulder, the boxer punched him to the ground and pushed him repeatedly. The prosecution's position was that Cordina had initiated the confrontation and was retaliating.

The court also heard allegations about a further exchange in which Cordina raised a golf club and O'Brien lunged towards him before blows were exchanged. Orndal said O'Brien was eventually restrained and no longer presented a threat, but Cordina then punched him again. Those claims form part of the prosecution account being considered at trial.

Cordina denied the alleged offence in his police interview. He said being shoved had made him feel threatened and described a later punch as an instinctive response to O'Brien's actions. His defence barrister, Tom Crowther KC, questioned whether people had been waiting for Cordina and suggested the confrontation had been set up.

Investigating officer PC Samuel Penman did not agree that such a setup was obvious from the witness video, but acknowledged that filming appeared to begin before physical contact. The court was told O'Brien's sister had expressed concern that her brother disliked Cordina and might have sought him out. Penman acknowledged it had been a mistake not to question her about those concerns. The trial continues.