Erasmus questions officiating as Prendergast faces hip-drop tackle citing
South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus questioned the consistency of rugby's disciplinary and refereeing decisions on Monday, saying he expected Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast to avoid suspension following a citing for an alleged hip-drop tackle. BBC Sport reported his comments from a media conference in Dublin, with no disciplinary outcome announced in its report.
Watch the highlights:
The incident involved Fiji captain Peceli Yato during Ireland's 43-15 victory on Saturday. According to the Irish Examiner, the tackle was not dealt with by the referee or television match official during the game. Erasmus said he considered it a red-card offence, but predicted a technicality would leave Prendergast available to face South Africa.
The case concerns a form of tackling outlawed at the start of the November international window. The 42 reported that World Rugby introduced the change on player-welfare grounds and that a citing commissioner must judge an alleged offence worthy of a red card before making a citing. That threshold does not itself establish a player's guilt or determine a suspension.
Erasmus also challenged the handling of South Africa's defeat by France. He claimed officials had missed 17 hip-drop or knee-drop tackles, including incidents he believed warranted penalties or yellow cards. BBC Sport reported that he questioned whether deliberately overlooking an offence would amount to match-fixing, while describing his remarks as not an accusation. These were his claims, not established findings against the officials.
The Irish Examiner reported that Erasmus compared Tadhg Furlong's clearance over an alleged groin grab with the nine-match suspension previously imposed on Jan-Hendrik Wessels. He argued that the different outcomes needed clearer public explanation, while acknowledging that he was not a legal expert. His comparison did not establish that the evidence or circumstances in the two disciplinary cases were identical.
Prendergast's availability therefore remained unresolved in the reports, despite Erasmus's prediction. The 42 said the competition's expedited disciplinary process can allow a player to accept foul play and a predetermined sanction, while a contested citing proceeds to a hearing. BBC Sport said it had approached World Rugby for comment on Erasmus's remarks.
Comments
0No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!