BBC review traces Manchester City transfer fees to 46 clubs in 19 leagues

Manchester City paid transfer fees to 46 clubs across 19 national league systems between summer 2009 and winter 2018, according to a BBC Sport review published on October 2. The report examines where the club's spending went during the period covered by its financial-rules case, as City appeal the verdict against them.

Watch the highlights:

BBC Sport put City's spending on players during 2009-2018 at roughly £1.2 billion, with net spending of about £900 million. Its club-by-club review covers senior signings and excludes free transfers, loans and academy graduates. The figures therefore describe a defined part of City's recruitment rather than every payment associated with bringing players into the club.

Premier League teams received just over a quarter of City's total transfer outlay in the period, the largest share among the leagues examined. City bought players from eight clubs in England's top flight and eight in Spain's La Liga. The report also identified a combined £13 million spent on two players from Championship clubs, showing that the direct payments extended beyond top-division teams.

Additional money reached clubs through sell-on agreements attached to earlier transfers. BBC Sport reported that Queens Park Rangers received roughly £9 million when Raheem Sterling moved from Liverpool to City in 2015. Barnsley collected about £7 million from John Stones' move from Everton in 2016, while Everton passed approximately £2.5 million to Wolves following Joleon Lescott's transfer to City in 2009. Those payments involved clubs that were not the direct sellers to City in those deals.

The BBC report distinguishes transfer fees from the wider costs of recruitment, which can include agents' fees, legal expenses, administration charges and signing-on bonuses. It also notes that football clubs spend money on wages, infrastructure and other operating costs. The transfer totals should therefore not be treated as an accounting of every destination for the income examined in the financial proceedings.

According to BBC Sport, the independent commission found that City had inflated their accounts by more than £900 million. The club has appealed the findings. The review documents the geographical reach of transfer payments, but does not establish how individual recipients would have performed without them or assign a precise sporting outcome to each payment.